February 6, 2025

filmsgraded.com:
Superman (1978)
Grade: 51/100

Director: Richard Donner
Stars: Christopher Reeve, Margot Kidder, Gene Hackman

What it's about. The planet Krypton, in a galaxy far far away, is doomed, so one of the humanoids, Marlon Brando, puts his infant son in a rocket and launches it to Earth, just in time before the planet explodes.

Because it is a movie, the baby lands on Earth without a scratch or needing a diaper change. Luckily for him, a middle-aged couple (Glenn Ford and Phyllis Thaxter) just happen to be driving by in their jalopy, and they adopt the baby, because why not.

Of course, the baby grows up to be Superman (first Jeff East, then Christopher Reeve). He has incredible powers of strength, speed, you name it, but for some reason decides to spend his time working as a cub reporter at a New York City newspaper run by stereotypical bossman Jackie Cooper.

Superman is soon entranced by the newspaper's star reporter Lois Lane (Margot Kidder). His romance with her is threatened by criminal mastermind Lex Luthor (Gene Hackman) and his idiot henchman Otis (Ned Beatty). Valerie Perrine plays Lex Luthor's moll.

How others will see it. Purportedly, Superman was the most expensive film ever, at the time of its production. But the film proved the adage that it takes money to make money, and the box office was about six times the cost. At the Oscars, the movie won only for its visual effects. John Williams was nominated for his score, but probably didn't win because it sounded a lot like his Star Wars score from the previous year, which did win.

Today at imdb.com, Superman has a fairly high user rating of 7.4 out of 10. Although the user vote total of 200K seems high, keep in mind that a previous Marlon Brando movie, The Godfather, has more than 2M user votes. The user reviews generally fawn over how entertaining the movie is. Some people note that the plot and characters don't hold up to close examination. But most folks don't care about that anyway.

How I felt about it. Christopher Reeve ruined the role of Superman for anyone else. It is unlikely that anyone else can be found more ideal. Although little known at the time (his only prior film role was in a small part in the obscure Charlton Heston vehicle Gray Lady Down), his performance was acclaimed. He not only looked the part, but he could play bumbling Clark Kent to perfection, as well as the easier role of Superman.

Reeve is unassailable here, as is Margot Kidder. But we have to wonder. Why would Lex Luthor, the alleged criminal mastermind, hire the dufus Otis (Ned Beatty) as his only employee? Why would he leave the swimming pool instead of watching Superman drown? Why would he send one of the missiles to Hackensack, New Jersey? Does he really hate his girlfriend's mother that much?

Why can Lois Lane fly when Superman is only touching her with a fingertip? Would she be so unlucky as to have the San Andreas fault open up while her car is directly over it? Why would Superman reversing the Earth's rotation make time go backwards? Why is Superman so interested in dating Lois Lane when there are so many bad guys to arrest? It seems he would concentrate on either one or the other. And why does the official movie poster for the film feature the Superman shield instead of any of its many celebrity actors?

Of course, the story exists solely to entertain us, and thus it only has to feel good, instead of making sense. There is no doubt that audiences were pleased, given the then-record box office for Warner Bros.

JustWatch.com